My Ultimate Potato Salad

45 degree angle view of a bowl of potato salad

This potato salad is an easy and delicious side dish. It is fully loaded with bacon, eggs and mayonnaise to create this amazing and crowd pleasing salad. This recipe is great for a weekend BBQ with your mates or with your family when pub food is on the dinner table.

Most times when I think of salads, the word healthy comes to mind. This is especially true when I picture your usual leafy green salads. However, even in the world of salads, there are universal forces at work which ensure balance is maintained. I am fairly confident that my potato salad was born to counter balance all things healthy. Yep, this little bad boy is sinful but soooooo good.

Top down view of my potato salad ingredients

My potato salad recipe over the years has had some significant changes, but a few things have remained true. There will always be too much bacon and eggs in my potato salad.  I have always loved bacon and eggs for breakfast and egg/mayo sandwiches. So why not combine it then multiply by 10 fold!

Then to bring it all together… I use my not so secret “store bought secret sauce”! I have used many brands and types of mayonnaise for my potato salad but traditional creamy mayonnaise by Praise is the clear winner. If I could sing (I have been told many times I can’t), I would be singing “Nothing Compares 2 U” by Sinead O’Conner to it. And trust me, if you have never tried it then give it a whirl. You may find out you can’t sing either which is always good to know!!!

Top down view of Praise mayonnaise

My Tips for Success

  1. Keep the skins on the potatoes, as this gives the salad better texture and prevents the potato chunks from breaking up and turning into mash.
  2. Smaller potato chunks are better. Not only is the potato faster to cook this way, but it means you don’t get mouthfuls of just potato.
  3. Cut the potato evenly so the pieces cook at the same rate. Nothing worse than having raw, hard potato in your salad.
  4. Assuming you have not executed tip no. 3 with perfect precision, always choose the largest piece of potato when checking to see if it is cooked through.
  5. This salad is best made the night before and left in the fridge to chill over night. However, if this is not possible, chill for two hours minimum.
  6. Use your hands when mixing the salad together. This will prevent the potato from breaking up too much.
  7. Lastly, don’t make this if you are trying to get into shape. It will undo all your hard work! Trust me…

Top down view of a bowl of potato salad

Thank you for visiting our food blog! If you like this recipe or any other recipe on the blog, please drop a comment and subscribe to our email list to always get the latest from our kitchen. It is free and your email will not be shared with anyone else.

If you make any of our recipes, Steph and I would love to see your creations! Please share it with us on Instagram using #scruffandsteph and @scruffandsteph! We would also appreciate any likes / shares / follows on our  Facebook page, Pinterest, Instagram and Yummly. Thank you for your support!

–  Scruff

My Ultimate Potato Salad

My Ultimate Potato Salad

Course Side Dish
Cuisine Australian
Prep Time 20 minutes
Cook Time 20 minutes
Total Time 40 minutes
Servings 6
Author Scruff

Ingredients

  • 6 large eggs
  • 1 kg baby potatoes or your choice, washed and chopped into small chunks
  • 1 tbsp oil, for frying
  • 4 - 5 rashers of bacon, roughly chopped

Dressing

  • 1/3 cup sour cream
  • 1 cup traditional creamy mayonnaise
  • 1/4 tsp salt
  • freshly cracked pepper, to taste
  • chives, finely chopped (can be substituted with spring onions / scallions)

Instructions

  1. Prep all your ingredients.

  2. In a large pot of boiling water, add the chopped potatoes and a good pinch of salt. Cook for roughly 15 minutes or until tender. 

  3. In another pot on medium heat, add the eggs and enough cold water to completely submerge the eggs. Once the water is boiling, give them 10 minutes then turn off the heat and set aside. 

  4. In a fry pan, add the oil and fry the bacon to your liking. 

  5. In a bowl, mix all the dressing ingredients together. Taste check and adjust to your taste. Reserve some chives and bacon to garnish at the end. 

  6. Peel the eggs and roughly chop. Make sure to break up any large chunks of cooked egg yolk. 

  7. Put some food handling gloves on and mix all the ingredients together in a large salad bowl.

  8. Taste check. If you believe the salad needs more punch, add more mayonnaise and mix through. If you believe it tastes too overpowering , add sour cream until the flavour calms down to your liking.  

  9. Garnish and keep in the fridge until serving. 

Advertisements
  • 79
  • 41
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  

10 thoughts on “My Ultimate Potato Salad

Leave a Reply